Part 6 -Right to Self-Determination- Ideological Warfare tactics of capitalists against socialism through concepts and theories
Ideological Warfare tactics of capitalists against socialism through concepts and theories
Part 6 - Right to
Self-Determination-The theoretical key (Right Vs Demand)
" Does
recognition of the right of nations to self-determination
really imply support of any demand of every nation for
self-determination? After all, the fact that we recognize the right of
all citizens to form free associations does not at all commit us." Lenin,
The National Question in Our Programme
The right and demand to self-determination
The largest confusion related to
Marxist-Leninist fundamental theories has been about the theory of
"State", "Defense of fatherland", and the "Right to
Self-determination"; therefore, an eclectic approach has been widely applied
by all sides concerned; eclecticism of bourgeois Liberals, chauvinists, nationalists,
and opportunistic ML tailgaters inevitably continued to blur the subject and
related confusion.
Taking the internationalist unity of the workers and oppressed people as the basic principle, Marxist-Leninist "Right to Self-determination" theory counter-aims at the cynical purpose of the bourgeoisie. Thus, the Importance of this theory should not be underestimated. Because, this theory, to counter the bourgeois approach, has both theoretical and tactical content.
Stalin states;
The merits of
this slogan are that it :
1) removes
all grounds for suspicion that the toilers of one nation entertain
predatory designs against the toilers of another nation, and therefore creates
a basis for mutual confidence and voluntary union;
2) tears
the mask from the imperialists, who hypocritically prate about
self-determination but who are striving to keep the unequal peoples and
colonies in subjection, to retain them within the framework of their
imperialist state, and thereby intensifies the struggle for liberation that these
nations and colonies are waging against imperialism. Stalin, Concerning the Presentation of the National
Question
Due to the tactical nature of the
theory, if and when the approach to the theory is partial, not to the entire
context, it will inevitably be perceived as contradictory.. Tweezing this
"dual - contradictory content" will bring about the practical
and "pseudo-right" results in accord with one's own ideological
understanding and purpose.
The Conflicting Appearance
When we carefully read the
writings of Lenin on the Right to Self-determination, what strikes the eye first
is that Lenin's comments appear to be in conflict.
On the one hand, Lenin and
Stalin, while making an internationalist obligation to defend "The
Right to Self-determination"; on the other hand, they indicate that the realization of this right could only be achieved by a socialist
revolution.
These examples of citations are related to the
self-determination RIGHTS that we often see and read.
""
Whoever..... does not fight against all national oppression or inequality, is
not a Marxist; he is not even a democrat "" Lenin, The
nationalist Bogey of "Assimilation"
"A nation
has the right freely to determine its own destiny. It has the right to arrange
its life as it sees fit, without, of course, trampling on the rights of
other nations. That is beyond dispute." Stalin, Marxism, and the
National Question - Nation
""...there
is one case in which the Marxists are duty bound, if
they do not want to betray democracy and the proletariat, to defend one special
demand in the national question; that is, the right of nations
to self-determination, i.e., the right to political
secession.''' Lenin, The National Programme of the R.S.D.L.P.
On the other hand, this excerpt
of the Self-Determination of Nations' transformation to an
active DEMAND appears to be contradictory;
" .... the
revolutionary experience of recent years has again confirmed that: the national
and colonial questions are inseparable from the question
of emancipation from the rule of capital; ........ the unequal
nations and colonies cannot be liberated without overthrowing
the rule of capital;...." Stalin, Concerning the Presentation of the
National Question
"the
Communist International’s entire policy on the national and
the colonial questions should rest primarily on a closer union
of the proletarians and the working masses of all nations and countries for a
joint revolutionary struggle to overthrow the landowners and the
bourgeoisie. This union alone will guarantee victory over
capitalism, without which the abolition of national oppression
and inequality is impossible." Lenin, Draft Theses on
National and Colonial Questions
So, there has to be a
theoretical and practical difference between defending and promoting the “RIGHT” and
its transformation into an agenda as “DEMAND”, since the first is absolute
for socialism and the latter, led by other classes, may contradict the
interests of the working class. For Marxists, the interests of the working
class and its struggle cannot be subordinated to any other
class and its struggle. Here the question arises.
Stalin summarizes this "duality", "contradiction" :
"while not
contradicting the rights of these nations, do
contradict "the precise meaning" of the
programme""", meaning the demand for secession.
""Obviously,
"the rights of nations" and the "precise meaning" of the
programme are on two entirely different planes. Whereas the "precise
meaning" of the programme expresses the interests of the
proletariat, as scientifically formulated in the programme of the latter,
the rights of nations may express the interests of any
class – bourgeoisie, aristocracy, clergy, etc. – depending on the
strength and influence of these classes. On the one hand are the duties
of Marxists, on the other the rights of nations, which
consist of various classes. " Stalin, The Caucasians, The
Conference Of The Liquidators
Attitude to the "Right
and to the actual "Demand"
Marxist Leninists always defend
and support the RIGHT. This constitutes the essence of tactical
theory, but when the actual DEMAND comes to the agenda, the
approach to support the DEMAND at any cost is contradictory
to the soul and to the fundamental theories of Marxism-Leninism. It would be a bourgeois approach to support and defend a DEMAND
without assessing its impact on the working class. Marxist Leninists have to assess
the specific conditions, and their practice should be in the interests of
laboring people and of their struggle. This fundamental approach is
never rendered secondary to any democratic demands.
As Lenin explains ;
""....
our unreserved recognition of the struggle for freedom of
self-determination does not in any way commit us to supporting
every demand for national self-determination. As the party of
the proletariat, the Social-Democratic Party considers it to be its positive
and principal task to further the self-determination of the proletariat in each
nationality rather than that of peoples or nations. We must always and
unreservedly work for the very closest unity of the proletariat of all
nationalities" Lenin, The National Question in Our Programme
Lenin clarifies the distinction
between Marxist and Bourgeois approach to the question;
""In
contrast to the petty-bourgeois democrats, Marx regarded every democratic demand without
exception not as an absolute, but as an historical expression of
the struggle of the masses of the people, led by the bourgeoisie, against
feudalism. There is not one of these demands which
could not serve and has not served, under certain circumstances, as an
instrument in the hands of the bourgeoisie for deceiving the workers. To
single out, in this respect, one of the demands of political democracy,
specifically the self-determination of nations, and to oppose it to the rest,
is fundamentally wrong in theory. In practice, the proletariat can
retain its independence only by subordinating its struggle for all democratic
demands, not excluding the demand for a republic, to its revolutionary struggle
for the overthrow of the bourgeoisie.. "" Lenin, Socialist Revolution,
and the Right of Nations to Self-Determination
The RIGHT to Self-Determination
İf in a reactionary society
where a woman is not entitled to any say at all, where women have no right to divorce, yet men can divorce her with just one word,
“divorced", the RIGHT to divorce for women must be
defended; in the same way, the RIGHT of a nation to secede should
be defended, in all circumstances. The RIGHT that the women
would win is for free, voluntary association and distinct from forcible
association. The most important difference not being understood is to defend
and support the RIGHT to divorce, and to
propose and support the actual DEMAND of divorce.
Lenin, while criticizing Semkovsky, states;
"It would
seem that even with Mr. Semkovsky’s mental abilities it is not difficult to
deduce that “the right to divorce” does not require that
one should vote for divorce! But such is the fate of those who
criticize -they forget the ABC of logic. "" Lenin, The
National Programme of the R.S.D.L.P.
Theory speaks of the RIGHT and
the DEMAND differently;
""our
programme (on the self-determination of nations) cannot be interpreted to
mean anything but political self-determination, i.e., the right to
secede and form a separate state" Lenin, Theses on the national
question
and explains the reasons clearly;
"The
championing of this right, far from encouraging the formation of
small states, leads on the contrary, to the freer, fearless
and therefore wider and more widespread formation of very big states and
federations of states, which are more beneficial for the masses and more fully
in keeping with economic development." Lenin, Socialism and War
The Attitude of the Russian Social-Democratic Labour Party Towards the War
So, the championed RIGHT is
not one suggesting separation, but one tactical support
theory that is aimed at free formation of the association.
Because, as noted below, anti-imperialist and socialist struggle is the
current agenda.
Since capitalism is the beginning
of the nations, inevitably, there are two historic periods to the right of nations' self-determination. ""The first is the awakening
of national life and national movements, the struggle against all national
oppression, and the creation of national states, so 'the awakening of
national life and national movements and the creation of national states'",
bourgeois national movements ."* Second period, a mature capitalism that is moving towards its transformation into
socialist society"* corresponds to the imperialist era.*
Lenin, Nationalist Bogey of assimilation
Lenin explains the dual approach
and purpose;
"" The
Marxists’ national programme takes both tendencies into account, and advocates,
firstly, the equality of nations and languages and the impermissibility of all
privileges in this respect ....; secondly, the principle of internationalism and uncompromising
struggle against contamination of the proletariat
with bourgeois nationalism, even of the most refined kind.. ""
Lenin, Nationalist Bogey of assimilation
"the main
thing today is to stand against the united, aligned front of the imperialist
powers, the imperialist bourgeoisie, and the social-imperialists, and for
the utilization of all national movements against imperialism for the
purposes of the socialist revolution. " Lenin, Marxism or Proudhonism?
If we want to stay true to the
tactical nature of the theory, in this period too, the RIGHT must
be supported in all circumstances. Lenin emphasizes that this RIGHT should
be recognized even in the most adverse conditions.
"The
bourgeoisie of the oppressed nations persistently utilize the slogans of
national liberation to deceive the workers....
The fact that
the struggle for national liberation against one
imperialist power may, under certain conditions, be utilized by
another "great" power for its own, equally imperialist, aims,
is just as unlikely to make the Social Democrats refuse to
recognize the right of nations to self determination as the
numerous cases of bourgeois utilization of republican slogans for the purpose
of political deception and financial plunder are unlikely to make the
Social-Democrats reject their republicanism" Lenin, Socialist
Revolution and the Right of Nations to Self-Determination
(We have seen articles trying to
pass theoretical sheath for the cooperation with imperialists, especially in
Syria, by the writers' eclecticism where the words " against
an imperialist power " are deleted.)
On the extent and limit of support, or what is to be supported at what degree,
and with what precautions, Lenin states ;
"Marxism cannot
be reconciled with nationalism, be it even of the “most just”,
“purest”, most refined, and civilized brand.............. The principle of
nationality is historically inevitable in bourgeois society and, taking this
society into due account, the Marxist fully recognizes the historical
legitimacy of national movements. But to prevent this recognition
from becoming an apologia of nationalism, it must be strictly limited to
what is progressive in such movements, in order that this recognition may not
lead to bourgeois ideology obscuring proletarian consciousness." Lenin,
Cultural National Autonomy - Critical Remarks on the National Question
When the DEMAND to secede is
on the agenda
Confusion and problems arise when the RIGHT comes to the actual agenda
as a DEMAND. These words of Lenin below clarify that the
decision to make an actual DEMAND should depend on the outcome of
the evaluation of concrete conditions. And he emphasizes that it should
be based on the interests of the struggle of the laboring
people. Marxist Leninists cannot say "yes" or "no" to
an actual DEMAND before making an assessment guarding the
interests of the working class and her struggle.
""
Does recognition of the right of nations to self-determination
really imply support of any demand of every nation for
self-determination? After all, the fact that we recognize the right of all
citizens to form free associations does not at all commit us, Social-Democrats,
to supporting the formation of any new association; nor does it prevent us from
opposing and campaigning against the formation of a given association as an
inexpedient and unwise step. We even recognize the right of the Jesuits to
carry on agitation freely,... "Lenin, The National Question in Our
Programme
""In
conformity with its fundamental task of combating bourgeois democracy and
exposing its falseness and hypocrisy, the Communist Party, as the avowed
champion of the proletarian struggle to overthrow the bourgeois yoke, must
base its policy, in the national question too, not on abstract and
formal principles but, first, on a precise appraisal of the specific historical
situation "'
""the
need constantly to explain and expose among the broadest
working masses of all countries, and particularly of the backward countries,
the deception systematically practiced by the imperialist powers,
which, under the guise of politically independent states, set
up states that are wholly dependent upon them economically, financially and
militarily." Lenin, Draft Theses on National and Colonial Questions
In reference to being
"practical" and saying "yes" or "no",
Lenin's criticism of Rosa's approach touches the core of the
subject;
""
"What does the demand for “practicality” in the national
question mean?
""It
means one of three things: support for all national aspirations; the
answer “yes” or “no” to the question of secession by any
nation; or that national demands are in general immediately
“practicable”.
The bourgeoisie,
which naturally assumes the leadership at the start of every national movement,
says that support for all national aspirations is practical. However, the proletariat’s
policy in the national question (as in all others) supports the
bourgeoisie only in a certain direction, but it never
coincides with the bourgeoisie’s policy. The working class supports
the bourgeoisie only in order to secure national peace (which
the bourgeoisie cannot bring about completely and which can be achieved only
with complete democracy), in order to secure equal rights and to create the
best conditions for the class struggle. Therefore, it is in opposition to the
practicality of the bourgeoisie that the proletarians advance their principles
in the national question; they always give the bourgeoisie only
conditional support. What every bourgeoisie is out for in the national
question is either privileges for its own nation, or exceptional advantages for
it; this is called being “practical”. The proletariat is opposed to all
privileges, to all exclusiveness. To demand that it should be
“practical” means following the lead of the bourgeoisie, falling into
opportunism. "
The bourgeoisie
is most of all interested in the “feasibility” of a
given demand—hence the invariable policy of coming to terms with
the bourgeoisie of other nations, to the detriment of the proletariat.
For the proletariat, however, the important thing is to strengthen its
class against the bourgeoisie and to educate the masses in the spirit of
consistent democracy and socialism.
This may not
be “practical” as far as the opportunists are concerned, but it is
the only real guarantee, the guarantee of the greater national equality
and peace, despite the feudal landlords and the nationalist bourgeoisie.
The whole
task of the proletarians in the national question is
“unpractical” from the standpoint of the nationalist bourgeoisie of every nation
because the proletarians, opposed as they are to nationalism of every
kind, demand “abstract” equality; they demand, as a matter of
principle, that there should be no privileges, however slight.
On the plea that
its demands are “practical”, the bourgeoisie of the oppressed
nations will call upon the proletariat to support its
aspirations unconditionally. The most practical procedure is to say a plain
“yes” in favour of the secession of a particular nation rather than in favour
of all nations having the right to secede!
The
proletariat is opposed to such practicality. While recognizing equality and
equal rights to a national state, it values above all and places
foremost the alliance of the proletarians of all nations, and assesses
any national demand, any national separation, from the angle of the
workers’ class struggle. This call for practicality is in fact merely a call
for uncritical acceptance of bourgeois aspirations. Lenin,
Practicality on National Question
Lenin outlines most clearly the
difference between the RIGHT and the DEMAND and
the cause for the rejection of demand;
"The
several demands of democracy, including
self-determination, are not an absolute, but only a
small part of the general-democratic (now: general-socialist) world
movement. In individual concrete cases, the part may contradict the
whole; if so, it must be rejected. It is possible that the
republican movement in one country may be merely an instrument of the clerical
or financial-monarchist intrigues of other countries; if so, we must
not support this particular, concrete movement, but it would be
ridiculous to delete the demand for a republic from the
programme of international Social-Democracy on these grounds." Lenin, Socialism,
and the self-determination of nations -
Marxism or Proudhonism?
In this citation, Lenin talks
about DEMAND being not absolute; chauvinists
cite this as for the RIGHT being not absolute.
The conditions for the DEMAND to
be supported can be summarized in the following quotes, where he
emphasizes quality over quantity;
" it
is not so much a question of the size of an organisation,
as of the real, objective significance of its policy: does its
policy represent the masses, does it serve them, i.e., does it aim at
their liberation from capitalism, or does it represent the interests
of the minority, the minority’s reconciliation with capitalism? "Lenin,
Imperialism and the Split in Socialism
A national(ist) movement could be
very strong with thousands of followers, yet for ML what matters is its policy
and practice in regard to its relationship with capitalism and
imperialism. Lenin states that movements seeking
exclusive rights to their own bourgeoisie against the other
bourgeoisie would not be supported.
If it is not through the
revolution, as an alternative to leaving in a peaceful manner, Lenin indicates
that it is reactionary .. In the words of Lenin, "separation through
legislation from one minority of the other is a reactionary idea." Lenin,
Socialism and War
Tactical content summarized
Tactical content and importance of Lenin's Right to Self-Determination theory can be
summarized in two ways.
1 - The right to
self-determination theory, based on the principles of Marxism and
internationalism, is the theory of the practice of providing voluntary
merger rather than by force and repression.
Lenin summarizes this tactical
approach as follows;
"" If, in
our political agitation, we fail to advance
and advocate the slogan of the right to secession, we
shall play into the hands, not only of the bourgeoisie,
but also of the feudal landlords and the absolutism of the oppressor nation..
"Lenin, Practicality on National Question
He explains the essence of the
theory and reasons;
"" If
we demand freedom of secession for ... all other oppressed and unequal
nations without exception, we do so not because we favor secession,
but only because we stand for free, voluntary association and merging as
distinct from forcible association. That is the only reason!. ""
"....no
self-respecting Social-Democrat will consider anyone opposing the right
of divorce a democrat, let alone a socialist. That is the crux
of the matter. All “democracy” consists in the proclamation and
realization of “rights” which under capitalism are realizable only to a very
small degree and only relatively. But without the proclamation of these
rights, without a struggle to introduce them now, immediately, without
training the masses in the spirit of this struggle, socialism is impossible. Lenin,
A Caricature of Marxism and Imperialist Economism
2 -National
movements force the ruling classes to decide
on problems
Lenin explains this
tactical approach as follows;
""
The right to self-determination” implies a democratic
system of a type in which there is not only democracy in general, but
specifically one in which there could not be an undemocratic solution
of the question of secession. ........When a democratic vote gives the
reactionaries a majority, one of two things may, and usually does occur:
either the decision of the reactionaries is implemented and
its harmful consequences send the masses more or less speedily over to
the side of democracy and against the reactionaries; or the conflict
between democracy and reaction is decided by a civil or other war, which is
also quite possible under a democracy..." Lenin, The National Programme
of the R.S.D.L.P.
In short, Marxist theory of Right
to Self Determination is a theory that weighs tactical content.
On the Attitude of Marxists
from each side
Always keep in mind "Bourgeois nationalism and proletarian internationalism—these
are the two irreconcilably hostile slogans that correspond to
the two great class camps throughout the capitalist world, and express
the two policies (nay, the two world outlooks) in the national
question..." Lenin, National Culture
In terms of the defense of Right,
on Marxists general attitude;
"Social-Democracy,
therefore, must give most emphatic warning to the proletariat and other working
people of all nationalities against direct deception by the nationalistic
slogans of “their own” bourgeoisie," Lenin, Theses on the national
question
"Those who
seek to serve the proletariat must unite the workers of all nations, and
unswervingly fight bourgeois nationalism, domestic and foreign. "
Lenin, National Culture
On the oppressor nations
Marxist-Leninist attitude ;
"" the
Great-Russian Marxist (oppressor nation's Marxist EA) will be
bogged down, not only in bourgeois, but also in Black-Hundred nationalism, if he
loses sight, even for a moment, of the demand for complete equality for the
Ukrainians (oppressed nations'), or of their right to
forum an independent state." Lenin, Nationalist Bogey of assimilation
On the oppressed nations' Marxist
attitude;
"workers who
place political unity with “their own” bourgeoisie above
complete unity with the proletariat of all nations, are acting against
their own interests, against the interests of socialism and against
the interests of democracy." Lenin, Theses on the national question
"If a
Ukrainian Marxist (Marxist of oppressed nation) allows himself
to be swayed by his quite legitimate and natural hatred of the Great-Russian
oppressors to such a degree that he transfers even a particle of this
hatred, even if it be only estrangement, to the proletarian
culture and proletarian cause of the Great-Russian workers, then
such a Marxist will get bogged down in bourgeois nationalism. "Lenin,
Nationalist Bogey of assimilation
Risk of wrong approach
Wrong approach to the theory, as
the condition of the current revolutionary struggle in Turkey is the sad
historical example of this, will end up as " an apologia of
nationalism, and will lead to bourgeois ideology obscuring
proletarian consciousness", creating division, hostility, and
hatred among the laboring masses of the given country.
The approach and
attitudes to the Right to self-determination cannot be identical to the
DEMAND for secession. The decision to support or not the DEMAND for
secession depends on the evaluation of the specific conditions in
relation to the interests of the working class and the socialist struggle at
that given time. If this fundamental approach is ignored, the theory of the
Right to Self-determination becomes the bourgeois theory of content. In Lenin’s
words;
""Self-determination
of nations demand that's it (the working class) we must subordinate the
interests of the struggle. The national question in our attitude to
our bourgeois-democratic attitude of the difference precisely lies in these
circumstances. Lenin, The National Question in Our Programme
"It
is beyond doubt that any national movement can only be
a bourgeois‐democratic movement,
since the overwhelming mass of the population in the backward countries consists
of peasants who represent bourgeois‐capitalist relationships. It would
be utopian to believe that proletarian parties in these
backward countries, if indeed they can emerge in them, can pursue communist
tactics and a communist policy, without establishing definite relations with
the peasant movement and without giving it effective support. However, the
objections have been raised that, if we speak of the bourgeois‐democratic
movement, we shall be obliterating all distinctions between the reformist and
the revolutionary movements. Yet that distinction has been very clearly
revealed of late in the backward and colonial countries, since the
imperialist bourgeoisie is doing everything in its power to
implant a reformist movement among the oppressed nations too. There
has been a certain rapprochement between the bourgeoisie of the exploiting
countries and that of the colonies, so that very often—perhaps even in
most cases—the bourgeoisie of the oppressed countries, while it does
support the national movement, is in full accord with the imperialist
bourgeoisie, i.e., joins forces with it against all revolutionary movements and
revolutionary classes. This was irrefutably proved in the commission, and we
decided that the only correct attitude was to take this
distinction into account and, in nearly all cases, substitute the term
“national‐revolutionary” for the term “bourgeois‐democratic”. The
significance of this change is that we, as Communists, should and will support
bourgeois‐liberation movements in the colonies only when
they are genuinely revolutionary, and when their exponents do not
hinder our work of educating and organizing in a revolutionary spirit the
peasantry and the masses of the exploited. If these conditions do not
exist, the Communists in these countries must combat the
reformist bourgeoisie. "Lenin, Report Of The Commission On The
National And Colonial Questions
Conclusion
Theory cannot be taken
independently from the class struggle, as an absolute theory by itself,
especially as an empty slogan without content. To defend and support the RIGHT and
to defend and promote DEMAND have different contents.
" If viewed from the Marxist
angle," as Lenin said," and if the slogans are
compared with the interests and policies of classes, and not
with meaningless 'general principles, ' we should approach the
theory from the standpoint of the class struggle". Lenin,
National Culture
In this sense, the Right to Self-Determination theory should NOT be understood in a
theoretical and practical context where the interests of class struggle is
subordination and dependent. On the contrary, parts and related theories should
be subjected to subordination for the interests of the
working class. Otherwise, it can not be Marxism, but would be bourgeois conciliation and bourgeois tailing.
Lenin puts it in concrete terms ;
"" The
national cause comes first, and the proletarian cause second, the
bourgeois nationalists say, with the Yurkeviches, Dontsovs and similar would-be
Marxists repeating it after them. The proletarian cause must come
first, we say, because it not only protects the lasting and
fundamental interests of labor and of humanity, but also those
of democracy .....without democracy neither an autonomous nor an independent nation is conceivable. "Lenin Nationalist Bogey of assimilation
In these days, seeing widespread examples of opportunist nationalist movement tailgating
(especially in Turkey), these words of Lenin must be digested;
“But we cannot be in favor of a war between
great nations, in favor of the slaughter of twenty million
people for the sake of the problematical liberation of a small
nation with a population of perhaps ten or twenty millions!” Of
course not! And it does not mean that we throw complete national
equality out of our Programme; it means that the democratic interests
of one country must be subordinated to the democratic interests of several and
all countries. " Lenin, The Discussion On Self-Determination
Summed Up - Marxism or Proudhonism?
These two quotes above and below
are crucially important in current situation where the DEMAND for secession in
Syria is on the agenda. Even though we are against the DEMAND, it
emphasizes the need to be opposed to any would be active action against the
demand taken by the bourgeoisie..
""be
unconditionally hostile to the use of force in any form
whatsoever by the dominant nation (or the nation which
constitutes the majority of the population) in respect of a nation that
wishes to secede politically." Lenin, Theses on the national
question
"The
Social-Democrats will always combat every attempt to influence
national self-determination from without by violence or by any injustice.
However, our unreserved recognition of the struggle for freedom of
self-determination does not in any way commit us to supporting every
demand for national self-determination." Lenin The National
Question in Our Programme
So while the RIGHT to
Self-Determination is supported in any event, as Lenin states, "a Marxist
can recognize the DEMAND for national independence only
conditionally, namely, on the condition indicated above" ( which
is subject to proletarian struggle).. But it is to the interests of
this struggle that we must subordinate the demand for
national self-determination.
"It
is this that makes all the difference between our approach to the
national question and the bourgeois-democratic approach. The bourgeois
democrat (and the present-day socialist opportunist who follows in his
footsteps) imagines that democracy eliminates the class struggle, and that is
why he presents all his political demands in an abstract way, lumped together,
“without reservations,” from the standpoint of the interests of the “whole
people,” or even from that of an eternal and absolute moral principle. Always
and everywhere the Social-Democrat ruthlessly exposes this bourgeois
illusion, whether it finds expression in an abstract idealist philosophy or
in an absolute demand for national independence." Lenin, The National
Question in Our Programme
In contrast to the
petty-bourgeois democrats, Marx regarded every democratic demand without
exception not as an absolute one. Every democratic
demand, including the right to self-determination, is secondary to the
interests of the working class and her struggle. While we defend and
support the RIGHT to self-determination, we do not say
"yes" to every actual DEMAND to secede without
assessing the concrete situation with the interests of the working class in mind.
Stalin clearly states this approach in "Foundation of Leninism;
"Leninism
.. recognizes the existence of revolutionary capacities in the national
liberation movement of the oppressed countries, and the possibility of using
these for overthrowing the common enemy, for overthrowing imperialism
This does not mean, of
course, that the proletariat must support every national movement, everywhere
and always, in every individual concrete case. It means that support must be
given to such national movements as tend to weaken, to overthrow imperialism,
and not to strengthen and preserve it. Cases occur when the
national movements in certain oppressed countries come into conflict with the
interests of the development of the proletarian movement. In such cases
support is, of course, entirely out of the question. The question of the
rights of nations is not an isolated, self-sufficient question; it is a part of
the general problem of the proletarian revolution, subordinate to the
whole, and must be considered from the point of view of the whole."
""no
Marxist, without renouncing the principles of Marxism and of socialism
generally, can deny that the interests of socialism are higher than the
interests of the right of nations to self-determination." Lenin,
On The History Of Question Of The Unfortunate Peace
We have established the
theoretical distinction: the RIGHT to self-determination is absolute; the
DEMAND is conditional, assessed based on the interests of the working class. We
have shown that Marxists support the RIGHT in all circumstances while assessing
the DEMAND based on concrete conditions. We now turn to a concrete case study
that exposes the sophistry of those who cry for self-determination for the
oppressor while denying it to the oppressed: Ukraine. This case study will
demonstrate how the theoretical distinction is weaponized — and how the
sophists side with the reactionary bourgeoisie.