Part 13 -Boycott- Ideological Warfare tactics of capitalists against socialism through concepts and theories
Ideological Warfare tactics of capitalists against socialism through concepts and theories
Part 13- Boycott
Marxist theories have been turned
into empty slogans, both unconsciously by Marxists and
consciously by imperialist ideologues, by isolating them from the
type of country, existing situation, and prevailing conditions. Through
phrase-mongering, tactical theories are presented as prescriptions
fitting every country, every condition, every stage, and situation.
This practice has been one of the core reasons for the defeat and hindrance
of revolutionary struggle.
" Our theory
is a guide to action, not a dogma," says Marx and Engels. Marxism
requires a concrete assessment of each specific situation and
condition in order to take a tactical stand and action thereupon. Marx, Letter to Sorge or Engels'
Critique of the Erfurt Programme
Marxists make decisions on every
tactical action from the point of view of the workers' class struggle
interests, by carefully and objectively assessing the existing
concrete conditions.
If we carefully read Lenin's
writings, the first thing we notice is that the question of boycott -
as well as the parliamentary form of struggle- varies depending on the
stage of revolutionary struggle. In " Left Wing Communism,"
he defines these periods as: the years of preparation of the revolution
(1903-05), the years of revolution (1905–07), the years of reaction (1907–10),
the years of revival (1910–14), the First Imperialist World War (1914–17), the
second revolution in Russia (February to October 1917).
Lenin defines "The years of preparation of the revolution (1903-05) as "the approach of a great storm is felt everywhere. All classes are in a state of ferment and preparation. ... The representatives of the three main classes, of the three principal political trends, the liberal-bourgeois, the petty bourgeois-democratic, and the proletarian-revolutionary trends, anticipate and prepare the approaching open class struggle by a most bitter battle on programmatical and tactical views. All the issues on which the masses waged an armed struggle in 1905-07 and 1917-20 can (and should) be studied in their embryonic form in the press of that time..... the classes were forging the requisite political and ideological weapons for the impending battles."
We do not see any mention of
Boycott at this stage.
He defines “The years of
revolution” (1905–07) as: "All classes come out into the open.
All programmatical and tactical views are tested by the action of the
masses. The strike struggle is unparalleled anywhere in the
world for its extent and acuteness. The economic strike grows into a
political strike, and the latter into insurrection. ... The Soviet form of
organization is born in the spontaneous development of the struggle. ... The
alternation of parliamentary and non-parliamentary forms of struggle, of
tactics of boycotting parliament and tactics of participating in parliament, of
legal and illegal forms of struggle, and likewise their interrelations and
connections -- all of this is distinguished by an astonishing richness of
content... "
And stresses the importance of
this stage: "Without the "dress rehearsal" of 1905, the
victory of the October Revolution in 1917 would have been impossible."
At this stage, he states: "..it is clear that our tactics at
present should first of all consist in support for the idea of
a boycott. However, contrary to the "far-left"
arguments and isolationist approach from the social democrats (in countries
like Turkey where the left wing democrats are in the ranks of opposition to
autocracy), Lenin states: " The very question of a boycott
lies within the bounds of bourgeois democracy. The working class is
not directly interested in it, but it is definitely interested in
supporting that section of bourgeois democracy which is more
revolutionary; it is interested in extending and intensifying political
agitation. A boycott of the Duma means a more vigorous appeal
to the people by the bourgeoisie, a development of its agitation, a
greater number of opportunities for our agitation, and a more intense political
crisis, which is the source of the revolutionary movement." Lenin,
The boycott of the Bulygin Duma
Fundamental difference from the
far-left, anarcho-Trotskyite call for boycott (none of which has any ties with
the laboring masses) and thus a "passive Boycott", Lenin had in
mind an active boycott. He states;
" Our tactics with regard to the State
Duma may be formulated in five points.... gaining the
adherence for the promotion of this agitation and of the
armed struggle of all revolutionary democratic elements, and of such
elements only,.... support of the boycott idea, which arose
among the Left-wing bourgeois democrats, with the purpose of making
it an active boycott in the sense of the most widespread
agitation ..."" Lenin, in the wake of the monarchist
bourgeoisie
In deciding on an active
boycott, " We must consider two questions," says
Lenin, "1) Is it possible to discuss, at election
meetings,... "together with" the class struggle,
socialism, and insurrection? 2) If that is possible, should the
former and the latter questions be discussed together, or the latter in
place of the former?" Lenin, Playing at Parliamentarism
That's why, for example, in a
country like Turkey where over 50% are voting for religious autocracy, and if
not all but very close to % 100 of the population lay their hopes in parliament
and parliamentary elections, to speak of an "active boycott",
especially without the participation of left-wing democrats, would be nothing but
an illusion.
Lenin's assessment, later in the
stage, at the start of 1906, in January, points to a major difference to
above. He says;
" The
class background of this split is clear: the Right wing of the
bourgeoisie is prone to come to terms with reaction through the Duma. The Left
wing of the bourgeoisie is prone to form an alliance with the
revolution, or at any rate to back it." Lenin, The state Duma,
and Social-Democratic tactics
Together with the changing of
conditions, the stand for boycott changes. In February he states:
"We
are continuing our struggle for a genuine assembly of real
representatives of the people. That assembly must be elected freely, and by all
alike, without any privileges for the landlords and the wealthy, and without
any hindrance on the part of the authorities and the police. Only a freely
elected constituent assembly of the whole people can be a genuine Duma and not
a sham one. “ Lenin, To all working man and women of the City of
St. Petersburg and vicinity
In March, he states;
"in
counter-posing revolutionary methods of struggle for freedom to the struggle
through the Duma, to devote especial attention during this
agitation to familiarizing the workers and the people as a whole with the
experience of the December uprising, which marks the beginning of a
higher stage of the revolutionary struggle for genuine freedom for the
people" . Lenin, Resolution of the St. Petersburg organization
on the RSDLP, on tactics of boycott
He clearly explains the boycott
tactics' relation with the existing, changing conditions. He says; " Our
readers know that we were in favour of boycotting Duma. At the
Congress we voted against the formation of a Social-Democratic parliamentary
group, for reasons that were given in detail in the resolution
published in Volna, No. 12. These reasons did not involve matters of
principle; they were prompted by considerations of prudence and
the practical conditions prevailing." Lenin, The
social-democratic election victory I Tiflis
In July, Lenin summarizes the
object of boycott;
" The object
of the boycott was to sweep away the Witte Duma.. its direct and
immediate object, the boycott nevertheless was indirectly of advantage in that,
among other things, it distracted the attention of the government. In this
case, too, as always, revolutionary tactics were the best means of
developing the class-consciousness and fighting efficiency of the proletariat,
and of indirectly ensuring the achievement of half-hearted reforms in
the event of failure to achieve complete victory."
In August, he explains the
approach to boycott;
" It should
be borne in mind that we have always presented this question concretely,
and in connection with a definite political situation...The
principal difference between revolutionary Social-Democracy
and opportunist Social-Democracy on the question of boycott is
as follows: the opportunists in all circumstances confine
themselves to applying the stereotyped method copied from a specific period in
the history of German socialism...The revolutionary Social-Democrats, on the
contrary, lay chief emphasis on the necessity of carefully appraising
the concrete political situation....it would be ridiculous to shut
our eyes to realities. The time has now come when the revolutionary
Social-Democrats must cease to be boycottists. We shall not
refuse to go into the Second Duma when (or "if") it is
convened. We shall not refuse to utilise this arena, but we
shall not exaggerate its modest importance." Lenin,
The Boycott
And in November;
" At the present time, a boycott
will not divert the forces of the government—the latter has certainly
learned the lesson of the past elections. The work of agitation and
organisation can be performed just as well by taking part in elections
as by boycotting them—unless the electoral law is changed very much for the
worse. If it is, then, perhaps, we may have to resort to the boycott again. But
we may not have time to bother with Duma elections at all if big
revolutionary battles begin again. Thus, boycotting remains a question
of expediency. The only point is that for the time being we do
not see sufficient grounds for a boycott. '' Lenin, Now history is
written
As we see from the foregoing,
even during the "Years of Revolution " approach to boycott was
differed based on the objective prevailing conditions.
Lenin defines the years 1907-190
as the " Years of Reaction" where "Tsardom scored
victory....The country's development along bourgeois lines proceeds with
remarkable speed. Extra-class and above-class illusions, illusions concerning
the possibility of avoiding capitalism, are scattered to the winds. The class
struggle manifests itself in quite a new and more distinct form....Now they
have to realize that this knowledge must be supplemented with the knowledge how
to retreat properly. .. Of all the defeated opposition and revolutionary
parties, the Bolsheviks effected the most orderly retreat, with the least loss
to their "army," with its core best preserved, with the least splits,
with the least demoralization, and in the best condition to resume the work on
the broadest scale and in the most correct and energetic manner. The Bolsheviks
achieved this only because they ruthlessly exposed and expelled the
revolutionary phrase-mongers, who refused to understand that one had to
retreat, that one had to know how to retreat, and that one had absolutely to
learn how to work legally in the most reactionary parliaments, in the most
reactionary trade unions, cooperative societies, insurance societies and
similar organizations."
In reference to the question of
boycott Lenin says ;
" The
case is presented in such a manner as if the
ultra-reactionary nature of the Third Duma by itself makes such a
method of struggle or such a slogan as the boycott necessary and legitimate. The
impropriety of such an argument is absolutely clear to any Social-Democrat
since there is no attempt here whatever to examine the historical
conditions of the boycott's applicability. The Social-Democrat who
takes a Marxist stand draws his conclusions about the boycott not from
the degree of reactionariness of one or another institution, but from
the existence of those special conditions of struggle that, as the
experience of the Russian revolution has now shown, make it possible to apply
the specific method known as boycott." Lenin, Against boycott
In his letter to Maria he states:
"I am against boycotting the Third Duma; I have been writing a
little piece on this subject which will probably soon be out. In my opinion that
slogan must not be revived unless there is a situation of heightened political
activity, unless there is a struggle against early constitutional
illusions....To declare a boycott at the moment would be
either premature bravado or the uncritical repetition of
slogans that have a glorious revolutionary past."
He clarifies the use of boycott
as following:
"active
boycott, as the experience .. has shown, is correct tactics ..
only under conditions of a sweeping, universal, and rapid
upswing of the revolution, developing into an armed uprising, and only in
connection with the ideological aims of the struggle against
constitutional illusions arising from the convocation of the first
representative assembly by the old regime;..........the tactics of boycott
could be appropriate only provided our efforts to convert the
trade-union upswing into a revolutionary assault were
successful." Lenin, The attitude of the Bourgeois Parties and
of the Worker’s Party to the Duma elections
Criticizing Maximov, Lenin states:
" In the political situation of June 1907, when Maximov
advocated the boycott, the mistake was still quite a small one.....in July
1907, in this district almost all the Social-Democrats without
exception were boycottists but, unlike Maximov, by June 1908 they had
the sense to understand that it would be unpardonable stupidity to
insist on "boycotting" the Third Duma. " Lenin, The
faction of supporters of Otzovism and God-building
"The
attempts of ultimatumism to assert its direct connection with the tactics
of boycott practiced by our wing of the Party during a particular
stage of the revolution" says Lenin in criticizing Otzovism and
ultimatumism, "merely distort the true meaning and character of
the boycott of the Bulygin Duma and the First Duma, which was quite
correctly applied by the overwhelming majority of our Party. By their attempt
to deduce, from the particular cases in which the boycott of
representative institutions was applied at this or that moment of the
revolution, that the policy of boycott is the distinguishing feature
of Bolshevik tactics, even in a period of counter-revolution, ultimatumism and
otzovism demonstrate that these trends are in essence the reverse side of
Menshevism, which preaches indiscriminate participation in all representative
institutions, irrespective of the particular stage of development of
the revolution, irrespective of whether a revolutionary upsurge exists or not."
Lenin, Resolutions of the Conference of the Extended Editorial Board of
Proletary
For those who learn from rote and
lack the application of Marxist dialectics, they " only memorised
a few slogans without grasping their meaning, could only repeat old phrases and
were unable to adapt the old principles of revolutionary
Social-Democratic tactics to the changed conditions." Lenin,
The Liquidation of Liquidationism
Lenin defines the years (1910–14)
as "The years of revival"; "At first the rise
was incredibly slow; then, following the Lena events of 1912, it
became somewhat more rapid. .... But the Bolsheviks would never have succeeded
in doing this had they not carried out a correct tactic of combining
illegal work with the obligatory utilization of "legal
possibilities." The Bolsheviks won all the labour seats
in the arch-reactionary Duma."
His writings in regard to boycott
are limited to the critique of Trotsky and his inflated phrases.
The First Imperialist
World War era (1914–17), he states;
"Legal
parliamentarism, with an extremely reactionary "parliament," is
of very useful service to the party of the revolutionary proletariat, the
Bolsheviks. The Bolshevik deputies are exiled to Siberia...... one of
the principal reasons why Bolshevism was able to score victory in
1917-20 was that ever since the end of 1914 it had been ruthlessly exposing the
baseness, loathsomeness, and vileness of social-chauvinism and
"Kautskyism" , and the masses later became more and more convinced by
their own experience of the correctness of the Bolshevik
views. "The Bolsheviks," he says, "called for an active
boycott of the Duma and concentrated their propaganda on the following
slogans: armed uprising, revolutionary army, provisional revolutionary
government. They used the boycott campaign to mobilize all the
revolutionary forces, carry out mass political strikes, and prepare
an armed uprising. The nationwide general political strike of October
1905 and the mounting wave of revolution prevented the elections, and
the Duma was never convened." Lenin, "Left-Wing"
Communism: An Infantile Disorder
In his letter to Inessa Armand, he
says that " in general, refusal to participate in
representative institutions is an absurdity; there are cases
when we have to refuse; there is a visual comparison for you which makes clear
that there is no contradiction between them."
For the second revolution in
Russia (February to October 1917), where " within a few days Russia was
transformed into a democratic bourgeois republic, more free -- under war
conditions -- than any other country in the world. The leaders of the
opposition and revolutionary parties began to set up a government; there
was no case of boycott. His writings are mostly related to the evaluation of
previous boycott tactics. In one of those writings he asks the question:
" Why did the tactics of boycotting the Third Duma prove
incorrect?" and responds, " Because they were based
only on the 'catchiness' of the boycott slogan....The objective
situation, however, was such that on the one hand the revolution was in a state
of collapse and declining fast....extra-parliamentary means of propaganda,
agitation and organisation were almost nonexistent or extremely
weak." Page 538
He repeats the same conclusion in
another writing: " The boycott of the
"Duma" by the Bolsheviks in 1906 was, however, a mistake, although
a small and easily remediable one. A boycott of the Duma in 1907, 1908
and subsequent years would have been a serious mistake and one
difficult to remedy." Lenin, Left-wing communism
As we see, except in the year of
revolution, boycott was not effective and proved to be wrong. Stalin notes,
" By boycott, the Bolsheviks usually meant an
active boycott, and not the mere passive abstention from
voting in the elections," and quotes Lenin: "The
boycott was unable to frustrate the convocation of the Duma because, as
subsequently became clear, it took place at a time when the revolution
was receding, when it was on the decline."
Stalin, in his reply to the Letter
of the Political Secretariat of the ECCI dated 25th October, 1933, states: The Cominternists are not correct. The boycott
proposed by them is not an active boycott in the Bolshevik spirit. It is a
simple abstention from elections: simply absenteeism. The
Bolsheviks have never observed such a boycott. They observe
only an active boycott accompanied by revolutionary activities; their
aim is to undermine or even to foil the elections. But this, the
solely acceptable boycott, is now not possible in Germany. Therefore the
Cominternists are wrong, and the Foreign Bureau of the Central Committee of the
CPG is correct. You must participate in the elections, cross out the fascist
list and vote for the option ‘no’ in the referendum. On such a basis, you must
form an anti-fascist front with the social-democratic workers and lead them so
that such an initiative can be undertaken on a communist platform and under
their leadership. Any other politics will serve only the interests of the
fascists and social-democrats.
Another example from
Stalin is "On the tactics of the Greek Communist Party Stalin stressed
the fact that the Greek communists earlier made an error with the boycott of
the parliamentary elections; he states, "Boycotting makes sense when it
brings about the failure of elections. Otherwise, a boycott is a foolish thing." Dimitrov's Diary, September 2, 1946
Treating the tactic of boycott as
a practice that fits every country, every situation regardless of the objective
conditions and the balance of power, especially in fascist, autocratic
countries, can only further isolate the revolutionaries from the masses
and thus serves the interests of the reactionary bourgeoisie. Boycott is a tactic
at a given right time in order to mobilize all the revolutionary
forces, carry out mass political strikes, and prepare an armed uprising. If
this situation and conditions do not exist, as Stalin puts it, a boycott
is a foolish thing
The boycott is the tactic of
abstention. But abstention is not always possible — and not always correct. In
other situations, the revolutionary must compromise — must ally with temporary,
vacillating, conditional allies. The ultra-left rejects this too. In Part 14,
we examine the question of compromise — when it is necessary, when it is
principled, and when the refusal to compromise becomes a betrayal of the
revolution.