The Path Of The Bukharinite Grouping From Opposition To Counter-Revolution
B. Ponomarev
THE PATH OF THE BUKHARINITE GROUPING FROM OPPOSITION TO COUNTER-REVOLUTION41
41 Bolshevik No. 5–6 of March 15, 1937
The Right-opportunist anti-party grouping of Bukharin — Rykov — Tomsky — Uglanov took shape and openly spoke out against the party at the beginning of the reconstruction period, in 1928–1929.
At the head of the opportunist group stood Bukharin, who many times
during his stay in the party fought in a bloc with Trotsky against Lenin.
Already during the imperialist war of 1914–1918, Bukharin, together
with Pyatakov and Radek, spoke out against Lenin on fundamental questions of
the struggle for revolution and the dictatorship of the proletariat. Bukharin
held opportunistic, anti-Leninist positions on the question of the proletarian
state, on attitude toward war, on the possibility of democratic movements in
the epoch of imperialism, on the national question, etc.
Bukharin wrote an article in 1916 where he preached the anarchist theory of the "blowing up of the state". Lenin showed right then that Bukharin was sliding toward anarchists:
"What distinguishes us from the anarchists is (a) the use of the state now and (β) during the revolution of the proletariat ("the dictatorship of the proletariat") — points of the utmost practical importance right now. (Bukharin has forgotten them!)"42
"...Bukharin was written to in VIII. 1916: 'let your views on
the state ripen.' He, not letting them ripen, rushed into print, as Nota bene, and did so in order to expose
Kautskyism, but helped them with his mistakes!!"43
Bukharin continued to insist on his anti-Marxist position long
afterwards. The article of Bukharin containing the specified mistakes was not
published by Lenin in the Bolshevik organ Social-Democrat
in 1916, but a year after Lenin's death Bukharin published this article
with the unacceptable statement that in the dispute over the state he was
right, and Lenin was not.
In 1915, Bukharin, together with Pyatakov, published special theses
directed against the Leninist theory of the right of nations to
self-determination up to secession. The opportunistic position of Bukharin on
the national question was in inextricable connection with his denial of the
possibility of any democratic movement in the epoch of imperialism. Lenin
characterized Bukharin's views as "imperialist economism".
42 Quoted from Stalin's book Questions of Leninism, p. 272, 10th ed.
Lenin then completely unmasked the anti-Marxist roots of the
Bukharinite position. And many years later, on the eve of his death, Lenin
wrote again about Bukharin:
"...his theoretical views can be attributed with very great
doubt to entirely Marxist ones, because there is something scholastic in him
(he never studied and, I think, never fully understood dialectics)"44.
Throughout the entire period of the imperialist war, Bukharin stubbornly tries to preserve his organizational isolation from Lenin, from the Bolshevik central organ, the Social-Democrat. At the Bern Conference of foreign sections of the RSDLP (Bolsheviks) in 1915, Bukharin, together with his so-called "Godite"45 group, sought organizational independence, striving in essence to create a center entirely against Lenin.
Counterposing to the Leninist position — the only correct one in the entire world workers' movement — his "theories," Bukharin slid into the swamp of the most arrant opportunists, centrists of the Kautsky and Trotsky type. The "Godite" group on the most important question of attitude toward war, following Trotsky, advocated the slogan of the "struggle for peace" and stated that it rejected "...any putting forward as a slogan for Russia of the so-called defeat of Russia"46.
45 Bozhi — village in Switzerland.
46 Proletarskaya Revolyutsiya No. 5 (40), p. 172, 1925.
Having spoken out against the Leninist slogan of the "defeat of your own government in the imperialist war," the Bukharin- Pyatakov group defended the most harmful, anti-Bolshevik position of forming the "United States of Europe," merging with Trotsky on the anti-Leninist platform of denying the possibility of the victory of socialism initially in a single, separately taken capitalist country.
Bukharin waged an impermissible, intriguing struggle against Lenin.
Taking advantage of the fact that financial funds were in the hands of his
group, Bukharin and Pyatakov demanded that Lenin in the journal The Communist, publish all articles
setting forth the point of view and views of persons close to them (Radek and
others). In response to the demand of the Bukharin- Pyatakov group, Lenin wrote
in the discussion: "This is not a discussion, the height of intrigue,
the height of baseness"47.
Then, after the Bern Conference, in March 1916, Lenin wrote about
Bukharin:
"...he (1) is gullible to gossip and (2) politically
diabolically unstable. The war pushed him toward semi-anarchist ideas. At the
conference which passed the Bern resolutions (spring 1915), he gave out theses
(I have them!) — the height of absurdity; disgrace; semi-anarchism"48.
By his struggle against Lenin, against the Leninist line that
ensured the victory of the revolution, Bukharin began his theoretical and
political activity. Many times after that he spoke out against Leninism,
against the party of Lenin — Stalin, trying to drag the party onto a ruinous
path.
During the period of the struggle for the Great Proletarian
Socialist Revolution, Bukharin, at the VI Congress of the party, spoke as the
rapporteur of the CC — Comrade Stalin, arguing that in the socialist revolution
the working class will be alone inside the country. Comrade Stalin, defending
the Leninist teaching on the driving forces of the revolution, exposed Bukharin
right then at the Congress.
"His analysis is incorrect in its very basis," Comrade
Stalin said. "In his opinion, at the first stage we are going toward a
peasant revolution. But after all, it cannot fail to meet, not coincide with
the workers' revolution. It cannot be that the working class, comprising the
vanguard of the revolution, did not fight together with it for its own demands.
Therefore I consider Bukharin's scheme unthought- out. The second stage,
according to Bukharin — the proletarian revolution with the support of Western
Europe without the peasants, who received land and were satisfied. But against
whom is this revolution directed? Comrade Bukharin, in his toy scheme,
does not give an
answer to this"49.
49 Protocols of the VI Congress of the RSDLP(b), p. 138, Partizdat, 1934.
Shortly after the establishment of Soviet power, when German imperialism moved its troops against the young socialist republic, threatening to strangle the revolution, Bukharin together with Pyatakov, Radek and Trotsky unleashed a fierce struggle against Lenin. The group of "left communists," contrary to the Leninist line on concluding peace with Germany, demanded waging war against it. And this meant in those conditions the certain ruin of the young, unfortified Soviet republic.
At the basis of Bukharin's position and his grouping lay the
Trotskyite theory of denying the possibility of building socialism in our
country. The "left communists" directly stated that "there is no
use thinking and talking about the isolated existence of the Soviet
country". Together with Trotsky, they asserted that the preservation of
the proletarian dictatorship and the construction of socialism in the Soviet
country are impossible without direct state support from the Western European
proletariat.
"The Russian revolution, having ceased to stake on the European
revolution, would thereby sign its own death warrant. In a single country,
moreover a backward country, it is impossible to carry out socialism,"
wrote the Bukharin- Pyatakov organ The
Communist (No. 2, 1918, article "Foreign Policy").
Defending their positions, which were ruinous for the socialist
revolution, the Bukharin-Pyatakov group for several months waged an unbridled,
anti-party campaign against Lenin.
The "left communists" directly merged with forces hostile to the proletarian dictatorship. All White Guardists, cadets, Mensheviks, SRs raised a frantic howl against the conclusion of peace. The Bukharin skaya group fell right into their arms; in its struggle against the party, the group reached the point where Bukharin conducted vile, treacherous negotiations with the Left SRs on the arrest of Lenin and replacing him with the group's protege — Pyatakov, the bitterest enemy of the people, now shot.
The vile tactics of alliance with enemies of the party and the
proletarian state Bukharin then applied more than once in order to achieve the
implementation of his line. The "left communists" created their
fractional center, which they counterposed to the Central Committee of the
party. At the VII Party Congress in 1918, against the rapporteur of the CC —
Lenin — spoke as co-rapporteur Bukharin. Lenin, scathing the adventurist policy
of Bukharin, said then that "...if you maneuver in a Bukharinite manner,
then you can ruin a good revolution nicely"50.
50 Lenin, Seventh Congress of the RCP(b), Works, vol. XXII, p. 335.
As a result of the policy of Trotsky and the Bukharinite group,
Germany managed to impose more severe peace terms on the Soviet Republic.
Trotsky and the "left communists," who were included in the
delegation that was to conduct negotiations with the German command in Brest on
concluding peace, failed to fulfill the telegraphic instructions of Lenin and
Stalin transmitted to them — to sign the peace treaty. German imperialism moved
troops on the offensive, and the Soviet government was forced to accept more
severe peace terms.
Lenin wrote:
"And that the new conditions are worse, heavier, more humiliating than the bad, heavy and humiliating Brest conditions, for this are to blame, in relation to the great Russian Soviet Republic, our poor-lefts Bukharin, Lomov, Uritsky and Co."51
"...facts show that Bukharin denied the possibility of a German
offensive, sowed illusions, which in reality, contrary to his desire, helped
the German imperialists, hindered the growth of the German revolution"52.
51 Lenin, A Serious Lesson and Serious Responsibility, Works, vol. XXII, p. 308.
52 The Communist No. 4 for 1918.
Lenin and his faithful and closest companions — Comrade Stalin,
Sverdlov and others — waged a huge, most intense struggle against the Bukharin
— Pyatakov — Radek group and against Trotsky. The victory of the Leninist line
and its implementation depended on the fate of the first socialist state in the
world.
"The 'left communists' spoke out against the entire economic
policy of the party. They accused Lenin and the Bolshevik party of
'degeneration,' in preserving only the 'external shell,' the 'firm' of
proletarian soviets, with a completely non- proletarian content"⁴.
At that moment, when the proletarian state embarked for the first time on solving the tasks of socialist construction, on establishing economic life on new, socialist bases, the "left communists" fought against the Leninist plan, fighting against discipline, control, accounting, etc.
Lenin qualified the "left communists" as direct conduits
of the policy of "frenzied petty bourgeois".
Thus, in the very first months of the existence of the Land of
Soviets, the party had to smash the Bukharinite grouping and Trotsky in order
to preserve the conquests of the Great Proletarian Revolution.
At the VII and VIII Party Congresses, Bukharin spoke against Lenin
on the question of the party program and on the national question. He achieved
the re-smuggling of his hostile Leninism views on the assessment of capitalism,
on the denial of the right of nations to self-determination, etc. At the VIII
Party Congress, Bukharin, resurrecting his mistakes of the war period, tried to
smuggle opportunistic views into the party program. He, proceeding from his
theory of "pure imperialism," proposed to throw out of the program
the definition of all pre-capitalist forms of economy, including commodity
economy and capitalism. Lenin, unmasking the anti-Marxist essence of the Bukharinite
position, said then:
"The program that does not speak of the foundations of
commodity economy and capitalism will not be a Marxist international program...
If a program is written like Comrade Bukharin wants, such a program will be
incorrect"53.
53 Lenin, VIII Congress of the RCP(b), Works, vol. XXIV, pp. 132 and 153.
The Party Congresses unconditionally condemned the Bukharinite
sallies.
On the eve of the transition to the New Economic Policy, Bukharin again spoke in cahoots with Trotsky with an anti- party, opportunistic platform against Lenin.
Trotsky, who started the trade union discussion of 1920–1921, put
forward the slogan of "statization" of trade unions in order to turn
the trade unions into a simple appendage of the state apparatus. Trotsky
proposed the method of compulsion in the work of trade unions, denied the
necessity of developing workers' democracy in trade union organizations, etc.
Trotsky, denying the role of trade unions as a school of communism, led things
to the destruction of one of the fundamental pillars of proletarian power. Such
a policy, as Lenin emphasized, led to a split of the party and trade unions, to
a complete break with the masses.
Bukharin, during the trade union discussion, spoke initially with the
so-called buffer platform, seeking to reconcile the party line defended by
Lenin and Stalin with Trotskyism. Soon Bukharin completely slid to Trotskyite
positions. Lenin fully exposed this Trotskyite line of Bukharin:
"So far 'chiefly' in the struggle was Trotsky. Now Bukharin has
far 'overtaken' and completely 'eclipsed' him, created an entirely new ratio in
the struggle, because he has agreed to a mistake a hundred times larger..."54
54 Lenin, Party Crisis, Works, vol. XXVI, pp. 92–93.
Lenin branded Bukharin's position then as a "break with
communism".
The Trotskyite-Bukharinite grouping launched a fierce struggle
against the party, creating with its fractional activity the threat of a split.
In the anti-Leninist fraction, together with Bukharin, again spoke opportunists
already known from the past: Pyatakov, Serebryakov, Preobrazhensky, Rakovsky,
and others.
Then, on the eve of the transition to NEP, which meant a major
turning point in the party's policy, Lenin directly pointed out to all united
opportunists (Trotsky, Bukharin, Pyatakov, Serebryakov, and others), insisting
on their mistakes, they would slide to enemies of the revolution. Addressing in
particular directly to Bukharin, Lenin said:
"There is an objective logic of fractional activity, which even
the best people, if they insist on the incorrect position occupied by them,
inevitably leads to a position in no way actually differing from unprincipled
demagogy... It remains to find in oneself,
using the expression of Lassalle, 'physical force (and character),' to
recognize the mistake, correct it and turn over this page of the history of the
R.C.P., either... either to clutch at remaining allies, whoever they may be,
'not noticing' any principles. The supporters of 'democracy' down to
lawlessness remained. And Bukharin slides to them, slides to syndicalism"55.
Bukharin did not heed the voice of the great leader of the
proletarian revolution, the founder of the Bolshevik Party.
Even at the transition to the reconstruction period, in 1925– 1927,
Bukharin committed a number of the grossest right- opportunistic mistakes. He
put forward the slogan "Enrich yourselves," which radically distorted
the entire policy of the party in the NEP period. Then Bukharin came out with
the theory of the "peaceful growing into of the kulak into
socialism," completely hostile to Leninism, in which he gave a
bourgeois-liberal concept of the development of the Soviet country. This theory
in reality led to the destruction of socialism, to capitalist restoration.
Proceeding from this thoroughly opportunistic theory, Bukharin fabricated a
number of right-opportunistic provisions on other issues (denial of collective
farms and their role in the socialist transformation of the village, distortion
of the Leninist cooperative plan, etc.).
The CC of the party, on the initiative and at the proposal of Comrade Stalin, gave a firm and resolute rebuff to Bukharin, exposing his opportunistic sallies. Bukharin outwardly recognized his mistakes then, but in reality hid under the rug these "theories" and in the period of socialist reconstruction, pushed them, deepened them to the end, and they became the basis for all restorationist, capitulatory platforms of the right- opportunistic grouping. Then Bukharin organized his "school," which included Slepkov, Maretsky, Tseitlin, Astrov, Kuzmin, Sapozhnikov, and others. Many of them managed to visit bourgeois and conciliatory parties of Cadets and SRs. All "schooling" grew on the yeast of anti-Leninist, Bukharinite theories, was educated in a spirit alien to Bolshevism, self-advertising and self-delusion. Bukharin taught the "school" a hostile attitude toward proletarian ideology, puffing up the interests of his "teacher" and his own interests in opposition to the interests of the party and the working class, instilling a hostile attitude toward the Leninist leadership of the party.
Bukharin instilled in the minds of his disciples the belief that in
the struggle against Lenin he was right, and not Lenin.
Participants of the "schooling" intensively tried to
popularize the right-opportunistic ideas put forward by Bukharin.
As subsequent events showed, the Bukharinite "school"
prepared "cadres" of the right-opportunistic opposition, which spoke
out in 1928. It formed the "cadres" of vile two-facers, terrorists,
enemies of the working class, rabid defenders of capitalist restoration.
Rykov, who, together with Bukharin, entered the leading
"troika" of right opportunists, held conciliatory positions in
relation to the Mensheviks, forward-looking people and other enemies of
Bolshevism in the period of tsarist reaction and revolutionary rise, 1908–1914.
In the decisive days of the struggle for the Great Proletarian Revolution, Rykov, together with vile strike-breakers and traitors of the revolution — Zinoviev and Kamenev — spoke out against Lenin, against the socialist revolution. Back at the April Conference of 1917, Rykov asserted in a Menshevik manner: "Russia is the most petty-bourgeois country in Europe. To count on the sympathy of the masses of the socialist revolution is impossible... Where will the sun of the socialist coup rise? I think that according to all conditions, the philistine level, the initiative of the socialist coup does not belong to us. We do not have the forces, the objective conditions for this"56.
The party, having cast off and exposed the Menshevik positions of
Kamenev, Rykov, went into battle against imperialism in October 1917, and the
working class achieved a world-historic victory. Rykov, who as early as October
25, 1917 fought against the party line on the uprising, in cahoots with
Zinoviev and Kamenev began a vile, treacherous struggle against the Soviet
government headed by Lenin, demanding the creation of a government "from
all socialist parties," i.e., giving up only the conquered power of the
proletariat into the hands of agents of
the bourgeoisie. Seeking to achieve the overthrow of the government of the
proletarian dictatorship and the departure of Lenin, Rykov together with
Zinoviev, Kamenev, Ryazanov and others, who resigned from the government,
announced their resignation from the Central Committee. He put forward vile
slander against Lenin, asserting together with the cadets and other
white-guardists that the Bolshevik government is maintained "by means of
political terror".
Lenin with all his might lashed out against these strike- breakers
of the revolution. In an appeal on behalf of the CC of the party (published in Pravda 20 (7) November 1917), Lenin
wrote:
"...Kamenev, Zinoviev, Nogin, Rykov, Milyutin and a few others came out yesterday, 17 (4) November, from the CC of our party — and three of the latter — from the Council of People's Commissars. But we declare that not for a minute
and not by a hair's breadth will the desertion act of several people
from the top of our party shake the unity of the masses marching behind our
party, and, consequently, will not shake our party"57.
For a number of years after this, Rykov, at Lenin's demand, was not elected to the leading organs of the party.
The right opportunist — Tomsky — also repeatedly spoke out with
opportunistic positions against Lenin. In the years of tsarist reaction and
revolutionary rise, he held conciliatory positions in relation to the
Mensheviks, rendering services to Trotsky together with Kamenev. In 1920–1921,
Tomsky went against Lenin, striving in fact for the separation of the trade
unions from the leadership of the party, and waged an intriguing struggle
against the Leninist Central Committee. At Lenin's demand, Tomsky was then
removed from the leadership of trade union work.
At the new, most important stage of the development of the party and the Country of Soviets, in the period of socialist reconstruction of the national economy, Bukharin together with Rykov, Tomsky, Uglanov again spoke out against Leninism, against the Leninist Central Committee of the party, at the head of which stood Lenin's loyal companion — Comrade Stalin, who had fought for decades together with Lenin against all anti-party groupings.
The right grouping began the struggle against the party shortly
after the XV Congress of the AUCP(b).
At this time the party, on the basis of the decisions of the XV
Party Congress, implemented the policy of an intensified offensive against the
capitalist elements of town and country. At the XV Party Congress, Comrade
Stalin put forward with all decisiveness the historical task:
"...to expand and strengthen our socialist commanding heights
in all branches of the national economy both in the city and in the
countryside, keeping the course toward the liquidation of capitalist
elements in the
national economy"58.
58 Stenographic report of the XV Party Congress, part I, p. 52, Partizdat, 1935.
The transition to the socialist reconstruction of the national
economy meant a major turning point in the development of the country of the
proletarian dictatorship. The party set and soon concretely wrote down in the
plan of the first five-year plan the greatest task — to implement decisive
measures for building a socialist society. It was necessary to transfer the
economy of the USSR to the rails of modern technology and turn the Soviet Union
from a backward, agrarian country into a leading, industrial country, fully
independent of world capitalism. This made it possible to raise the country's defense
capability to the proper level, to ensure the organization of a crushing rebuff
to the military attack of imperialists.
Especially great were the tasks of socialist reconstruction in the countryside. In the countryside then predominated backward, individual peasant farming. The task consisted in transferring fragmented agriculture onto the path of large-scale, collective farming and thereby ensuring the creation of the economic basis of socialism in the countryside and liquidating the possibility of the restoration of capitalism in the Soviet Union.
The working class went into the final, decisive battle with
capitalism inside the country. The resolution of the tasks of the
reconstruction period had to finally and unconditionally resolve the question
of the victory of socialism in the USSR.
Representatives of capitalism, first of all the most numerous of
them — the kulak class, these very beastly enemies of socialism, as Lenin
characterized them, did not want to leave the stage voluntarily. They rendered
fierce and stubborn resistance to the offensive of the proletarian dictatorship.
With the transition to the reconstruction period, the class struggle in the
country greatly intensified.
Reflecting the resistance of class enemies to the socialist
offensive of the proletariat, right opportunists spoke out against the party's
line. The party had to wage a major struggle against the Rights, to smash them,
like all other enemies, in order to ensure the implementation of the
Lenin-Stalin general line, which led to the great victory of socialism in the
USSR.
Bukharin's group spoke out before the July Plenum of the CC AUCP(b) in 1928. When discussing in the CC the grain procurement difficulties and ways of resolving the grain problem, Bukharin spoke with the slanderous assertion that the implementation of the grain procurement policy in the winter of 1927–1928 allegedly led to a "disjunction" with the peasantry. Bukharin proposed complete freedom of private trade, not limited by state regulation. Bukharin spoke out against the sweeping of collectivization.
Having received a rebuff, Bukharin voted at the plenum along with
everyone else, but in reality, as it soon transpired, organized vile,
behind-the-scenes negotiations with the Trotskyites to fight against the party.
In October 1928, on the eve of the first five-year plan, Bukharin
came out with the article "Notes of an Economist," directed against
the country's industrialization policy, against the Bolshevik rates of
socialist construction. In this article, Bukharin put forward the openly
opportunistic slogan "leveling down to the bottlenecks". Bukharin, in Notes of an Economist, demanding the
suspension of socialist construction, tossed out the "catchphrase"
that "from the bricks of the future one cannot build real factories,"
which became a slogan not only for right opportunists, but also for
counter-revolutionary wreckers of the Ramzin, Kondratiev, and other types.
At that time, on the basis of the directives of the XV Party
Congress, the five-year plan was being compiled. Bukharin, in Notes of an Economist directed his blow
against the five-year plan. He directly wrote about the "unreality"
of this plan, joining thereby the chorus of foreign and internal enemies of the
Soviet country, who wailed about the "unrealistic plans" of the Bolsheviks.
"...from the report of Economic Life it is seen that too large demands presented by the five-year plan to the budget make it 'unrealistic,' and 'unreality' is a rather significant flaw," wrote Bukharin.
"Notes of an Economist" became at that time the main platform of the rights. For all those who slid onto the right-opportunist path, it was a signal for unification, for the struggle against the Lenin-Stalin line of the party.
The rights organized and came out to fight against the party. In the
autumn and winter of 1928, an acute struggle unfolded against the Rights in the
Moscow organization. A group of workers of the Moscow Party Committee, headed
by Committee Secretary Uglanov, came out in defense of the right-opportunist
line; it tried to rally the opportunistic activists to win over to the side of
the Rights the Moscow party organization in order to speak out together with
Bukharin, Rykov, and Tomsky against the Lenin-Stalin Central Committee.
Uglanov, Kotov, and following them district committee secretaries:
Ryutin, Kulikov, Yakovlev, Komsomol IC secretary Matveev, and some others
gathered "their people" at meetings, unfolded right-opportunist
criticism of the general line of the party, slandered the party, and discussed
measures for overthrowing the Leninist leadership of the CC headed by Comrade
Stalin.
At the heart of Uglanov's line lay the views put forward in Bukharin's "Notes of an Economist": the struggle against the country's industrialization and the collectivization of agriculture, against the offensive against the kulak. Uglanovites put into circulation the rabidly right "theory" of the "calico bond" of the working class with the peasantry. They argued that it is necessary to develop not heavy, but light, in particular textile, industry, and slandered about the "degradation" of agriculture.
In August and September, articles by "Uglanov's agitprop"
appeared in the press. In one of them, tolerance toward deviations was openly
preached. In another article, the Leninist theory of the socialist
transformation of the poor-middle peasant masses of the peasantry was replaced
by the right- opportunist and restorationist in essence policy of
"uninterrupted concessions" to the entire peasantry, put forward by
Tomsky back in July 1928.
Thus, instead of the party's line on the industrialization of the
country, which ensured the creation of a socialist economy and the socialist
transformation of the countryside, the Rights proposed their own policy, which
led to the growth of capitalist elements and the restoration of capitalism,
which doomed the Soviet country to becoming a toy in the hands of capitalists.
Comrade Stalin, summing up the results of the first five-year plan, said that if the party had refused to implement the country's industrialization, then "...we would have had in such a case a military intervention, no non-aggression pacts, but a war, a war dangerous and mortal, a bloody and unequal war, because in this war we would have been almost unarmed before enemies having at their disposal all modern means of attack"59.
To implement the five-year plan, it was necessary first of all to
smash the right opportunists.
The Bolsheviks of the Moscow organization opposed the Uglanov group
and Bukharin, Rykov, and Tomsky standing behind it. The overwhelming majority
of the active members and the entire Moscow organization gave a decisive rebuff to the Rights.
An enormous role in the struggle against the opportunists was played
by the address of the CC AUCP(b) to all members of the Moscow organization and
Comrade Stalin's speech at the Plenum of the Moscow Committee in October 1928.
Comrade Stalin pointed out that right opportunism reflects the resistance of
capitalist elements — and above all the kulak — to the socialist offensive,
that the party must rout the Rights and give a merciless rebuff to the
conciliators in order to ensure the construction of a socialist society.
Uglanov's supporters, representing a small handful of right
opportunists, were quickly exposed and isolated. The Moscow organization, under
the leadership of the CC, routed the right opportunists in its midst, expelled
them placing at the head of the organization leaders devoted to the Leninist
party and CC.
Comrade Molotov was elected Secretary of the Moscow Committee —
Secretary of the CC AUCP(b), a staunch Leninist and fighter for the victory of
socialism.
At the November Plenum of the CC in
1928, Comrade Stalin focused the attention of the entire party on the struggle
against right opportunism, exposing its line leading to the undermining of the
power of the working class and to the restoration of capitalism in the USSR.
The party emphasized with all its might that in the reconstruction period the
right deviation is the main danger. "...the right deviation reflects the
resistance of the main elements of outliving classes; it is precisely for this
reason that the right deviation is the main danger of our time in the party"60 — called
Comrade Stalin.
Seeking to disrupt the implementation of the party line and the
struggle of the party against right opportunism, Bukharin, Rykov, and Tomsky
applied the "politics of resignations".
They acted in the same way as Rykov had acted at one time, deserting
in the first period of Soviet power, or as Bukharin had acted during the
Brest-Litovsk Peace, fighting against Lenin. Before the CC Plenum in November
1928, Bukharin, Rykov, and Tomsky submitted resignation statements. The
"politics of resignations" was a clear demonstration testifying to
the unwillingness to implement the party line and to the preparation of new
attacks against the party. The Central Committee rejected the resignations and
proposed to Bukharin, Tomsky, and Rykov to remain at work and implement all
decisions of the party. But the rights in reality did not submit to the
decision of the Central Committee and unfolded an even more stubborn anti-party struggle.
In December 1928, during the VIII Trade Union Congress, a struggle
against the rights unfolded in the trade unions.
Tomsky, standing then at the head of the AUCCTU, tried to lead the
trade unions along the right-opportunist path and use them as a support for the
rights in the struggle against the party. Instead of mobilizing trade union
members to struggle for rapid rates of industrial development, to help the
collectivization of the village, to struggle against bureaucracy, the right
opportunists from the AUCCTU tried to keep trade union masses away from these
tasks and thereby disrupt the implementation of socialist reconstruction. A
striking manifestation of this line of theirs is the fact that socialist
emulation and shock work began bypassing the leadership of the trade unions and
amidst stubborn sabotage on their part.
Tomsky and his grouping directly slid into Menshevik positions; they
Menshevistically opposed the trade unions to the proletarian state.
At the VIII Trade Union Congress, the right opportunists unfolded a fierce struggle against the party. The CC AUCP(b) sent a group of party workers headed by CC Secretary L. M. Kaganovich to the leading trade union organizations to implement the party line in the trade unions. Tomsky's grouping met this measure of the CC AUCP(b) on bayonets. Particularly fiercely, the rights resisted the introduction of Comrade Kaganovich into the Presidium of the AUCCTU. The introduction of Comrade Kaganovich into the Presidium of the AUCCTU, an irreconcilable fighter against opportunism and a loyal exponent of the Leninist-Stalinist line of the party, ensured the rout of opportunism in the trade unions and the implementation of the party line in trade union leadership.
Despite the maneuvers of Tomsky's grouping, the rights in the trade
unions suffered complete defeat. The overwhelming mass of communists — members
and workers of trade union organizations — staunchly defended the party line,
rebuffed the rights, and when, after the VIII Trade Union Congress, Tomsky tried
to speak out against the party again, he was exposed, and the Central Committee
removed him from work in the AUCCTU.
In January 1929, Bukharin, at a meeting dedicated to the memory of
Lenin, spoke with a report that radically distorted the Leninist views on the
party's policy and the proletarian government regarding the peasantry. Not a
word was said in his report about the class struggle in the village, about the
struggle against the kulak, about the sweeping of collectivization, etc.
Bukharin's report was directed with its spearhead against the party's policy,
against the production forms of the bond, against the socialist reconstruction
of the country.
At the same time, in January 1929, new scandalous facts of the treacherous behavior of Bukharin and the entire "troika" of the rights were uncovered. In a Trotskyite counter-revolutionary leaflet discovered at that time, it was reported about Bukharin's negotiations with Kamenev. The investigation established that Bukharin, on instructions from the right center, back in July 1928, through Sokolnikov, conducted secret, behind-the- scenes, treacherous negotiations with Kamenev, who, after hypocritical repentance, was only recently readmitted to the party. During these negotiations, Bukharin maliciously slandered the party leadership, asserted that a crisis in the country was inevitable, and agreed with Kamenev on creating a bloc to fight against the party.
In his negotiations with Kamenev, Bukharin acted similarly to how he
had acted during the conclusion of the Brest-Litovsk Peace, when he agreed with
enemies of the party and the proletariat — the Left.
SRs, waging an unbridled, vile campaign against Lenin. Now he
likewise spoke out against Comrade Stalin, negotiating with the bitterest
enemies of the party, strike-breakers of October, on the struggle against the
Lenin-Stalin plan for building socialism in our country.
The uncovering of Bukharin's negotiations with Kamenev vividly
highlighted all the behavior of the right opportunists, showed how far the
Rights had gone in their anti-party struggle, how false and hypocritical their
behavior had been during the July and November plenums of the CC 1928, when
they declared that they were subordinating themselves to the will of the party.
Here again all the anti-Bolshevik properties of Bukharin were
vividly revealed. With a hypocritical air of sanctity, masking himself with a
mask of sincerity, Bukharin, right at the very beginning of the struggle, carried
out foul, intriguing, fractional secret machinations against the party and its
leadership.
Bukharin concluded a bloc with the bitterest, unmasked enemies of Bolshevism, who only recently, in November 1927, had participated in an anti-Soviet demonstration on the streets of Moscow and Leningrad.
During the discussion in the CC AUCP(b) of these treacherous
actions, Bukharin, Rykov, and Tomsky spoke out on all questions against the
party line. At the April Plenum of the CC 1929, where the question of the
behavior of the rights was raised, they came out with fierce attacks against
the party's policy. To the general line of the party, they opposed their right-
opportunist platform. At the plenum, the party discussed the great plan of the
first five-year plan. This plan ensured the victory of socialism in the USSR,
the liquidation of capitalist elements and the eradication of all their roots.
Our party's Central Committee at this historical, responsible moment, mobilized
all forces for the struggle to implement the plan for the victory of socialism.
Bukharin's grouping spoke out against this plan, seeking a retreat
before capitalist elements seeking the implementation of its own line, which
led to the restoration of capitalism in our country. All anti-Leninist,
right-opportunist views of Bukharin, repeatedly condemned by the party, were
revealed here in an expanded form. "The theoretical basis" of the
position of the Rights was the anti-Marxist, anti-Leninist theory of the
"dying out of the class struggle under the dictatorship of the
proletariat," the theory of the "peaceful growing of the kulak into
socialism".
Marxism-Leninism teaches that after the conquest of power by the proletariat, the class struggle does not stop, but becomes even more acute. Countering this teaching, Bukharin argued that the transition to socialism would proceed peacefully, spontaneously, without the aggravation of class struggle. "The main network of our cooperative peasant organizations," wrote Bukharin, "will consist of kulak-type, [and] 'labor' type cooperatives, growing into the system of our all-state organs... On the other hand, kulak cooperative nests will just as well through banks, etc. grow into this same system; but they will to a certain extent be a foreign body, like, for example, concession enterprises" (Path to Socialism and Workers- Peasants Union)61.
The line of Bukharin, the ideologue of the kulak, served in practice
the class enemies of the proletarian state. All development of the country
spoke of the fact that capitalist elements launched a fierce struggle in
response to the strengthening of the positions of socialism. In those very
days, when the rights with foam at the mouth defended Bukharinite
"theories," the kulaks, in response to the development of the
collectivization of the village, in response to grain procurements, organized
arsons of procurement stations, waged malicious, counter-revolutionary
agitation against collective farms, against the delivery of grain, buried grain
in pits, killed defenders of collectivization, leaders of party and Soviet
organizations in the village. The kulak, sensing his end, which
collectivization and the victory of socialism were bringing him, went to the
most beastly methods of struggle.
And the Bukharinite group argued at that time at the April Plenum that in the country there is no kulak at all, that "all the peasantry is poor" and those who are considered kulaks are also 61 poor, possess negligible means and have absolutely nothing to fear.
Quoted from Questions of Leninism, p. 251, 10th ed.
The rights at the plenum spoke out against the five-year plan,
seeking to disrupt its approval and implementation. Rykov proposed his
"two-year plan" — a plan of retreat before capitalism.
The rights proposed abolishing emergency measures, through which the
party provided the country with grain. Instead of grain procurements inside the
country and pressure on the kulak strata, the rights proposed importing grain
from abroad. They opposed state farms and collective farms, insisting on the
development of individual farming, including kulak farming, in the village.
The rights spoke out against the new production forms of the bond
between the working class and the peasantry and the entire economic policy,
proposing to build based on free trade and the development of market
spontaneity. This Bukharinite proposal on "normalizing the market"
meant the abandonment of the leading role of the proletarian state, full
freedom of trade, freedom of development for the private trader in the city and
the kulak in the village.
Bukharin came out with vile, white-guard slander, stating that the
party is conducting a "policy of military-feudal exploitation of the
peasantry". Straight from Milyukov — the leader of the Cadets — Bukharin
borrowed slanderous attacks against the party of Lenin — Stalin.
The platform of the rights with complete clarity showed that the
rights are the kulak agency in the ranks of the party.
Comrade Stalin, in his historical speech at the April Plenum of the
CC AUCP(b) in 1929, fully exposed the right-opportunist platform of Bukharin and
his grouping and showed that it serves the cause of restoring capitalism.
Comrade Stalin mobilized the entire party to the struggle for the
great plan of building socialism, for the implementation of which it was
necessary first of all to rout the opportunists in the ranks of the party62.
"...to abandon the struggle against the right deviation means
to betray the working class, to betray the revolution"63.
The right opportunists received a crushing rebuff at the CC AUCP(b)
Plenum. Comrades Molotov, Kaganovich, Voroshilov, Kuibyshev, Kirov,
Ordzhonikidze and other members of the CC exposed the Bukharinite grouping, its
anti- Leninist essence and defended the Stalinist five-year plan.
The CC AUCP(b) categorically condemned the behavior of Bukharin,
Rykov, and Tomsky, removed Bukharin and Tomsky from their posts, and
categorically warned the Rights that in case of violation of party decisions
and failure to comply with party discipline they will be expelled from the
elective organs of the party.
The party, exposing and eradicating manifestations of right
opportunism in theory and in practice, mobilized the attention of all
organizations, striving to raise Bolshevik vigilance in the struggle against
kulak agency. A crushing rebuff was received
The party in this period waged a major struggle against Bukharin in
the Comintern. Backed by the VI Congress of the Comintern, Bukharin had drafted
theses in which he asserted that capitalism is being restructured and
strengthened, at a time when the capitalist world was on the eve of the
fiercest economic crisis, and the party was saying that the dismantling of
capitalist stabilization and the aggravation of the crisis of capitalism were
taking place. In Bukharin's theses, the question of the struggle against right
opportunists and conciliators was not posed, and a number of other political
mistakes were made. The AUCP(b) delegation in the Comintern exposed Bukharin's
opportunistic sally and introduced essentially new theses at the VI Congress of
the Comintern.
Bukharin, repenting further and further into the opportunist swamp,
became the center of attraction for all right-opportunist elements in the
Comintern and organized them for the struggle against the Leninist Bolshevik
line. At the heart of the Bukharinite grouping's position lay the theory of
"organized capitalism," which doomed the proletariat to subordination
to capitalist exploitation and led to the abandonment of revolution.
Throughout the entire period after the VI Congress of the Comintern, Bukharin, rallying opportunists in various sections of the Communist International, defended his rabidly opportunistic positions. But in the ranks of the Communist International, Bukharin received a resolute rebuff.
The X Plenum of the ECCI, gathered at the end of 1929, exposed
Bukharin, removed him from work in the Comintern and called upon all fraternal
communist parties to cleanse their ranks of right opportunists.
Having approved at the XVI Party Conference, despite the resistance
of the Rights, the five-year plan in the "optimal variant," the party
under the leadership of Comrade Stalin unfolded a heroic struggle to implement
this plan. For the party's general line, embodied in the concrete indicators of
the five-year plan, went the heroic builders of the Stalingrad Tractor Plant,
the Dnieper expanses, the working class of all Soviet lands. The
collectivization of poor-middle-peasant farms unfolded widely, smashing the
fierce resistance of the kulaks.
At the November Plenum of the CC AUCP(b) in 1929, when the party was
summing up the results of the "year of the great breakthrough" and
outlining further tasks of socialist construction, the right leaders again
spoke out against the party line, applying a new maneuver. It was already clear
to everyone that the positions of the Rights were smashed by life, by the rapid
growth of industry and the collective farm movement. But the rights did not
want to lay down arms before the party; they stated at the November Plenum of
the CC that they had disagreements with the party only on the question of
emergency measures, and "the remaining disagreements are removed".
The Plenum exposed the anti-party maneuvers, all their behavior at
the plenum as preparation for new attacks against the party. The Central
Committee branded the speech of the rights as "...a fractional maneuver of
political bankrupts, analogous to the 'capacitatory' maneuvers of the
Trotskyites, who more than once used their allegedly conciliatory statements as
a method of preparing new attacks against the party"64.
The CC Plenum warned the Rights that "in case of the slightest
attempt on their part to continue the struggle against the line and decisions
of the ECCI and CC AUCP(b), the party will not hesitate to apply corresponding
organizational measures to them".
At the same time, the Plenum issued a decision that the propaganda
of the views of right opportunism and conciliation with it is incompatible with
membership in the AUCP(b).
The capitulatory, restorationist essence of the position of right
opportunism was fully understood by all open enemies of socialism, who fought
for the restoration of capitalism in the USSR through wrecking and sabotage.
The leaders of wrecking organizations — the "Promparty," the
"Trudarms," "Labor Peasant Party" — these graybeards and
ideologues of capitalism — stated that the line of the right opportunists
coincided with their line. Kondratiev — an overt defender of the kulak and
participant in the kulak, counter-revolutionary organization — directly stated
that he desired the victory of right opportunism.
64 AUCP(b)
in Resolutions, part II, p. 396, Partizdat, 1936.
Ramzin, during the trial of the "Promparty" participants, stated that one of the main methods of wrecking was the artificial reduction of
the rates of development of the national economy. This line, in its direction, coincides with the guidelines of the right deviation in the communist party, why, during the implementation of artificially truncated minimalist plans through
planning and governmental organs from the center, an original bloc was created
with the right communists, which greatly facilitated for the center the
approval of such plans" (from Ramzin's testimony at the
"Promparty" trial).
The Central Committee of our party repeatedly warned the Rights that
they are sliding into the camp of open enemies, bourgeois restorers.
At the XVI Party Congress, where the historical victories of the
party in the matter of the country's industrialization and the collectivization
of the village were summed up, leading to the USSR entering the period of
socialism, Comrade Stalin uncovered and exposed the general line of the enemies
of the Bolshevik party, the enemies of socialism — the Trotskyites and right
opportunists.
The Trotskyites for many years directly fought against the
Leninist-Stalinist teaching on the possibility of building socialism in a
single country.
About the Bukharinite grouping, Comrade Stalin said at the XVI Party
Congress:
"...right deviationists slide in practice to the point of view
of denying the possibility of building socialism in our country"65.
Thus, the Trotskyites and Rights converged on the fundamental, decisive question, denying the possibility of building socialism in our country. Even earlier, in a number of speeches, Bukharin had slipped into the Trotskyite position. In 1922, at the IV World Congress of the Comintern, he asserted that genuine socialism cannot be achieved by the Soviet Union. "...Socialism can grow exclusively on the soil of the existing, and therefore it can be said that various socialist forms in a certain sense will be a continuation of former capitalist forms... We can say completely openly that Russian socialism, compared to others, will look Asian... The proportion between the developing and unyielding rationalization in our country, the proportion between industry and the peasantry, etc., etc., all these features of the backwardness of our economic development will find expression in backward forms of our socialism".
This Bukharinite provision, put forward back at the beginning of NEP, is directly linked with the liquidatory, right- opportunist platform of Bukharin in the period of socialist reconstruction, when Bukharin in practice slid to the point of view of denying the possibility of building socialism in our country. The question of building socialism in the USSR is a programmatic question that determined the line of development of the party of Lenin — Stalin, which determined the fate of the first socialist country and the liberating struggle of the peoples of the whole world. Under the banner of the Lenin- Stalin teaching, our party won world-historic victories.
Right opportunists, fighting against the methods and ways of
building socialism implemented by the party, proposing instead of the plan of
offensive against capitalist elements their own plan — the plan of retreat,
spoke out against the party on the fundamental programmatic question — on
building socialism in the USSR.
Having united with Trotskyism on a common platform on
the programmatic question, the Rights took the common path with the Trotskyites
of vile counter-revolutionary struggle.
At the XVI Party Congress, Rykov and Tomsky, seeing that the right
opposition was completely smashed, that the party masses everywhere were giving
a crushing rebuff to right-opportunist sallies, spoke out with penitent
speeches. Bukharin was not present at the Congress. The Congress, summing up
the results of the party's struggle against right opportunism, declared the
views of the right opposition incompatible with membership in the AUCP(b).
In addition, the XVI Party Congress in a special point of the
decision, indicated:
"The Congress draws the attention of the entire party to the fact that opportunists of all stripes, especially the Rights, apply a new maneuver, expressed in the formal recognition of their mistakes and in formal agreement with the general line of the party, without confirming their recognition by work and struggle for the general line, which in reality means only the transition from open struggle against the party to covert struggle or waiting for a more favorable moment to resume the attack on the party. The party must declare the most merciless war on this kind of two-facedness and deception and demand from all who recognize their mistakes by active defense of the general line of the party to prove the sincerity of their recognitions. Non-fulfillment of this requirement must entail the most decisive organizational measures"66.
66 AUCP(b) in Resolutions, part II, p. 406, Partizdat, 1936.
The subsequent course of events showed all the correctness and
exceptional political importance of this decision.
As facts showed, the Bukharinite grouping, verbally recognizing the
erroneousness of its line and assuring of its devotion to the party, in reality
waged anti-party, fractional, subversive activity.
The rights from 1930 changed their methods of struggle: they went
underground, conspiring their organizations. Having taken this path, the rights
slid into the abyss of counter- revolution. All activity of the right renegades
was conspiratorially led by the center of the rights: Bukharin, Rykov, Tomsky,
and Uglanov.
1931, 1932 were years of the greatest victories of socialist construction, years of overcoming the greatest difficulties. These were years of intensified class struggle for the construction of socialism in the USSR. And it was precisely at this time that right opportunists, who had slid into counter- revolution, again spoke out against the party and Soviet power. At the end of 1932, the counter-revolutionary grouping of Ryutin and others was uncovered, showing where the right- opportunist opposition had come from, how it had slid into the abyss of counter-revolution, defending an openly restorationist platform, organizing a vile, terrorist gang.
This platform was developed by the counter-revolutionary center of
the Rights and put it into circulation, hiding its participation for purposes
of conspiracy under the guise of the "Ryutin platform". The Ryutin
group showed the merging and unification of the rights with the Trotskyites. The
line, started in 1928 during Bukharin's negotiations with Kamenev, culminated
in the creation of a common counter-revolutionary organization. The exposure of
this group uncovered the unfolding of underground anti-Soviet activity of the
Rights and Trotskyites, their vile counter-revolutionary terrorist methods and
methods of struggle, masked by two-faced statements of agreement with the party
line.
The Ryutin grouping was, as the Presidium of the CCC AUCP(b)
indicated in its resolution of October 9, 1932, a grouping "...of traitors
to the party and the working class, trying to create through underground means
under the fraudulent flag of 'Marxism-Leninism' a bourgeois, kulak organization
for the restoration of capitalism in the USSR, and in particular, the kulak
system"67.
67 AUCP(b) in Resolutions, part II, p. 669, Partizdat, 1936.
Into this counter-revolutionary group entered such people as Ryutin, who held in 1928–1930 a rabid right-opportunist position and was already expelled from the ranks of the AUCP(b); Bukharin's closest disciples: Slepkov, Maretsky, and Petrovsky P.; remnants of the "workers' opposition" like Kayurov; Uglanov and a number of others who were in the right opposition. Along with this, active participants in the Trotskyite counter-revolutionary organization, a representative of the Lefts — Stan and others — operated in this grouping.
Taking part in this counter-revolutionary grouping were Bukharin,
Tomsky, and Rykov on the one hand, Zinoviev and Kamenev on the other.
If the right opportunists, speaking out in 1928–1929 against the
party line, waged a struggle against the country's industrialization and the
collectivization of agriculture, against the policy of liquidating the kulak as
a class, sought the disruption of the construction of socialism in the USSR,
then, speaking out against the party at the end of the first five-year plan,
the rights waged a struggle for the surrender of capitalism to the already
created foundation of socialist economy embodied in the greatest enterprises of
the five-year plan, in 200 thousand collective farms, in 5 thousand state
farms, etc.
By this time the party had ensured enormous historical victories of
socialism: unemployment was completely liquidated in the country, the
fulfillment of the five-year plan in four years was ending, in the main grain
regions total collectivization was completed and on its basis the liquidation
of the kulak as a class.
The final, decisive battle with capitalism inside the country was
ending with the great victory of the party, ensuring the ruin of capitalism forever, the impossibility of its restoration.
The class enemy at this time, by all methods, passing over to the
struggle "by stealth," tried to destroy the socialist economy created
by the heroic labor of workers and collective farmers.
This resistance of class enemies and, above all, the extremely
embittered kulak was reflected by the Ryutin counter- revolutionary grouping,
which united with the Trotskyites, and the soon-to-be-exposed
Eismont-Tolmachev-Smirnov A.P. grouping, created by the center of the Rights.
They took the path of vile methods of struggle, with which Trotskyite
counter-revolutionaries operated.
S. M. Kirov said in October 1932 about the vile activity of the
Rights and Trotskyites united in the Ryutin grouping:
"Recently, the bankrupt remnants of broken party oppositions,
right and left opportunists, have merged into a single counter- revolutionary
group, setting as their goal the restoration of the bourgeois-capitalist
system. In this group we find not a few familiar people, partly thrown out of
the party, partly remaining in its ranks through two-facedness. These pitiful
bankrupts tried to shake the iron might of the proletarian dictatorship. They
will meet a crushing rebuff from the party and the working class; they have
signed their final verdict; they are political corpses"68.
68 Kirov, Leningrad Bolsheviks between XVI and XVII Congresses of the AUCP(b), p. 302, Partizdat, 1934.
The Eismont-Tolmachev counter-revolutionary underground group, which was one of the offshoots of the counter- revolutionary organization of the rights, was uncovered at the end of 1932. Rotten, degenerated, extremely embittered against the leadership of the party and government, these vile spawn of right opportunism organized terrorist groups to fight against the party. They sought, like the Ryutin group, the implementation of the program for restoring capitalism in our country. Rykov, Tomsky, Schmidt, and others were exposed at that time in ties with the Eismont group and others. Once again they vilely deceived the party, strenuously denied everything, and tried to cover up the tracks of their criminal activity.
Being exposed as exponents of the aspirations of outliving exploiter
classes, as defenders of the restoration of capitalism in the USSR, the right
renegades closed ranks in their circle, full of hatred for the party and its
leadership, which personified the victory of socialism and its further
victorious march.
Isolated from the masses and unable to count on any support in the
ranks of the party and working people, the right renegades, having slid from
opportunism to counter-revolution, following the Trotskyites, took the vilest,
most treacherous path of terrorism. The leaders of the Bukharinite group began
to seek allies among the bitterest enemies of socialism and the Soviet country.
For all eternity branded with the curse of the working people, traitors of the
revolution — Mensheviks, SRs and the scum of the vile servants of the fascist
bourgeoisie — Trotskyites — Bukharin, Rykov, Tomsky and their adherents sought
to gather.
Participants of the Bukharinite "school," degenerated to the end, imbued with mortal hatred for the party and the country of socialism, quickly passed their path from unbridled opportunistic sallies to the party line to vile terrorist conspiracies. The Bukharinite upbringing of the "school" in the spirit of self-glorification, on principles and traditions alien to Bolshevism, bore its poisonous fruits now. Defending the restoration of capitalism in the USSR, participants of the Bukharinite "school" came out with open preaching of the struggle against Marxism. These people, who earlier had engaged in proclaiming anti-Leninist Bukharinite theories, now together with foreign enemies of the proletariat openly stated that "Marxism has outlived itself". Together with Hitlerite- fascist executioners seeking the "eradication of Marxism," came out in this way those brought up in the Bukharinite stinking, rotting "school" — its disciples.
The rights were aware of the conspiratorial, criminal activity of
the freaks of humanity, Hitler's bloody mercenaries — the
Trotskyite-Zinovievite bandits — and became their accomplices.
Bukharin, as was stated in the testimony of the defendants in the case of the Trotskyite anti-Soviet center, was most closely connected through the Trotskyite-fascist bandit Radek with the Trotskyite center. The center of the Rights, proceeding from the community of its platform with the platform of the Trotskyite bandits, organized the struggle against the Soviet people, against its leaders. On instructions from the Bukharinite center, Tomsky conducted negotiations with Zinoviev and Kamenev, with murderers, saboteurs, spies, and wreckers. The Bukharinite center also instructed Uglanov to establish ties with Zinoviev, and they agreed on organizing terrorist gangs to commit villainous crimes against the peoples of the USSR and the working people of the whole world. The Rights created their terrorist groups, which included Uglanov's adherents like Kulikov, Kotov, Bukharin's disciples: Slepkov, Tseitlin, Kuzmin, Sapozhnikov, and others.
Bukharin, following Radek, "theoretically substantiated" his treason. They preached a vile, counter-revolutionary theory, which is a continuation and development of Bukharin's theory of "organized capitalism," arguing that fascism represents a high stage of organized economy and managed to overcome the contradictions inherent in capitalism. They defended the counter-revolutionary theory of the impossibility of the victory of socialism in the USSR and proposed surrendering to fascism all the great conquests of the revolution. United by a common platform, a common hatred for the leader of the party and working people — Comrade Stalin, for the leading workers of the party and government, who organized the struggle for the great victory of socialism, smashed the Trotskyites and rights - the Trotskyite and Bukharinite centers conducted their vile, treacherous, counter-revolutionary activity, preparing the doom of the already won socialism.
The curse of the peoples of the USSR and working people of all
countries, with which the Trotskyite-Zinovievite gang is forever branded, falls
also on the heads of the renegades — accomplices of the Trotskyite bandits.
All facts, which have now become known to the party, show what vile,
thoroughly hypocritical and two-faced statements of the rights about stopping
the struggle and agreement with the party line were. The counter-revolutionary
groupings organized by the rights, exposed some time ago, showed that the right
opportunists passed over to vile, counter-revolutionary activity.
But only now was it possible to uncover the activity and platform of
the center of the rights — Bukharin, Rykov, Tomsky, Uglanov and their
adherents, directed toward the restoration of capitalism in our country.
Trotskyism has long ceased to be a political current. It has no
roots in our country, where exploiter classes are liquidated, and socialist
reconstruction is carried out, ensuring the eradication of capitalist elements.
Trotskyism degenerated into a band of fascist lackeys, murderers, saboteurs,
spies, who even consider it possible to disclose their present monstrous
program to their accomplices. Trotskyism has roots in the camp of imperialism,
in the capitalist encirclement of the USSR, in the camp of mortal enemies of
socialism and the working masses.
The rights also ceased to be a political current. Their social base,
primarily the kulak, was liquidated as a result of the victory of socialism.
The rights, who slid into the abyss of counter-revolution, represent a gang of
criminals and enemies of the people. Capitalism, which still exists in
five-sixths of the globe, tries to use in its struggle against the country of
socialism the last remnants of capitalist elements, Trotskyites and Rights, as
a gang of criminals ready to execute the most villainous fascist crimes.
The Bolshevik party, carrying out its great historical role of
creating a new, communist system, destroys and sweeps from the road all those
who fight against it, against the socialist society, against the Soviet people.
Despite the machinations of the dark forces of outliving the capitalist world and its agency, our party under the leadership of the Lenin-Stalin Central Committee, headed by Comrade Stalin, on the lessons of the struggle against enemies of socialism, mobilizing all communists and all working people of the USSR, raising their vigilance for winning further victories of socialism.
